As restaurant owners strive to balance customer satisfaction, staff motivation, and overall business operations, understanding the pros and cons of this practice becomes crucial. Whether you’re contemplating this policy to enhance staff incentives or to streamline tipping practices, this quick post will shed light on the multifaceted implications of such a decision.

Con: Customers May Feel Alienated

If you’re adding a mandatory service charge, you must declare it upfront, so customers know what to expect. An optional service charge is, as the term suggests, optional. That is, customers may wish to pay it or not. In many cases it still provides a conundrum, as an optional service charge doesn’t necessarily go to the person who served the customer. Therefore, they may feel obligated to also pay a tip, which some customers may find irritating. Some restaurant owners are choosing to use a service charge instead of raising menu prices, though the end effect on the customer is the same: their meal will cost more than they expected.

Pro: Tipping is at an All-Time Low

With Americans being increasingly affected by inflation, many are avoiding ‘optional’ extra costs wherever they can. Tipping culture has declined in recent years for this very reason; in fact, 66% of people reported having negative feelings towards the practice. An optional service charge is a good option to gently encourage customers to pay extra for the service they’ve received. One thing to keep in mind is that the use of optional service charge payments are at the restaurant’s discretion. They don’t need to go to any one server, so employees may wind up unhappy anyway.

Smaller Restaurants Will be Affected More

While tips and optional service charges do differ, both give customers the option to reward a restaurant and its staff for a great meal. The biggest question is whether or not this should really be optional or mandatory. As always, the smaller restaurants and businesses will be the ones to suffer most. High-end establishments may impose ‘optional’ charges which hardly anyone will dare to not pay. They’ll also use these to entice people to come work for them, with promises of higher and more consistent pay. Meanwhile mandatory charges may alienate some customers, again, largely in smaller restaurants.

Make it Optional but Don’t Overcomplicate

We think an optional charge is the best way forward. It makes up for the current lower rates of tipping, yet encourages customers to give a little extra. Keep it simple by highlighting the ‘optional’ nature of the service charge on your restaurant’s checks, but don’t over-complicate or over-explain. Your main focus should be on service and, of course, food – if that’s great, the rest will follow.